Piper logo Piper logo
Piper logo small
  • About
  • Intellectual Property
  • For Legal Professionals
  • News-Blog
  • Our Services
  • Our People
  • Careers
  • Contact Us
  • Searching
  • Protection
  • Exploitation
  • Enforcement
  • IP Management
  • New Zealand
  • Australia
  • PCT
  • Pipers Bulletins
  • Affiliations
  • IP Articles
  • WorldWide Patent Attorneys
  • Resources
  • Case Studies

Menu

  • About
    • Our Services
    • Our People
    • Careers
    • Contact Us
  • Intellectual Property
    • Searching
    • Protection
    • Exploitation
    • Enforcement
    • IP Management
  • For Legal Professionals
    • New Zealand
    • Australia
    • PCT
    • Pipers Bulletins
    • Affiliations
  • News-Blog
    • IP Articles
    • WorldWide Patent Attorneys
    • Resources
    • Case Studies
New Zealand
  • NZ Law Summary
  • NZ Legislation
  • Important NZ Cases
  • Indigenous Culture & Traditional Knowledge
  • NZ Public Holidays
  • NZ Law Summary
  • NZ Legislation
  • Important NZ Cases
  • Indigenous Culture & Traditional Knowledge
  • NZ Public Holidays
Important NZ Cases

Important New Zealand IP Case Law

Court decisions issued in other British Commonwealth countries often carry weight in New Zealand courts (and Intellectual Property Office hearings), particularly in the absence of New Zealand case law on the issue. New Zealand strengthened its own precedent system in 2004 when the Supreme Court was established to hear appeals from the Court of Appeal, which were previously heard by the Privy Council in the United Kingdom.

The following New Zealand IP cases are relevant either for their own findings or for endorsing findings from other countries with influential jurisprudence.

Patent Cases
Pfizer Inc v Commissioner of Patents

(CA 22/03, 28th June 2004)

Hammar Maskin AB v Steelbro New Zealand Ltd

(2010 NZCA 83, 24th March 2010)

Ballance Agri-Nutrients Ltd v Ravensdown Fertiliser Co-Op Ltd

(CIV 2009-404-2171, 4th March 2011)

Interpharma (NZ) Ltd v Commissioner of Patents

(CIV 2010-485-506, 7th October 2011)

Stewart v Franmara Inc

(CIV 2011-404-02584, 19th July 2012)

Assa Abloy New Zealand Limited v Allegion (New Zealand) Limited

(2016 NZHC 1738; 29 July 2016)

Trade Mark Cases
Higgins Coatings Pty Ltd v Higgins Group Holdings Ltd

(CIV 2009-485-2594, 30th June 2010)

Coombe v Coca-Cola Amatil (NZ) Ltd

(CIV 2010-485-816, 8th April 2011)

NV Sumatra Tobacco Trading Company v New Zealand Milk Brands Limited

(2011 NZCA 264, 14th June 2011)

AA Insurance Ltd v AMI Insurance Ltd

(CIV 2010-485-2427, 2nd November 2011)

Manhaas Industries (2000) Ltd v Fresha Export Ltd

(CIV 2011-485-1255, 24th July 2012)

Roby Trustees Ltd v Mars NZ Ltd

(2012 NZCA 450, 1st October 2012)

The Scotch Whisky Association v The Mill Liquor Save Ltd

(2012 NZHC 3205, 30th November 2012)

The Coca-Cola Company v Frucor Soft Drinks Ltd

(2013 NZHC 3282; 10th December 2013)

InterCity Group (NZ) Limited v Nakedbus NZ Limited

(2014 NZHC 124; 12th February 2014)

Sexwax Incorporated v Zoggs International Limited

(2014 NZCA 311; 9 September 2014)

Tasman Insulation NZ Ltd v Knauf Insulation Ltd

(2015 NZCA 602; 16 December 2015)

Copyright Cases
Tiny Intelligence Ltd v Resport Ltd

(2009 NZSC 35, 8th April 2009)

Oraka Technologies Ltd v Geostel Vision Ltd

(2013 NZCA 111, 18th April 2013)

Karum Group LLC v Fisher & Paykel Financial Services Ltd

(2014 NZCA 389; 13th August 2014)

Pleadings & Evidence Cases
Frucor Beverages Ltd v Rio Beverages Ltd

(CA 55/00, 22nd March 2001)

Pfizer Ireland Pharmaceuticals v Eli Lilly and Co

(CA 8/05, 8th December 2005)

Merial Ltd v Bayer New Zealand Ltd

(2013 NZHC 2197; 28th August 2013)

Daimler AG v Sany Group Co Ltd

(2014 NZCA 421; 28th August 2014)

Fair Trading & Passing Off Cases
Holdfast New Zealand Ltd v Mechanical Plastics Corp

(2013 NZCA 335; 30th July 2013)

Confidential Information & Trade Secrets Cases
Foot Science International Ltd v Xu

(2014 NZHC 645; 2nd April 2014)

Share this Print this Contact the author